|
Issue
to Consider |
Mutual
Funds |
Separate
Accounts |
Curian
Capital |
|
Investing within an overall financial plan |
Usually not. An investor
selects a fund with little regard to an overall financial plan, assessing
their risk tolerance, and/or proper asset allocation. |
Usually the broker
(relationship manager) will invest to ensure immediate cash flow needs are
met. Generally, a long range financial plan and assessment is not used. |
Curian only works with
financial advisors that will create an overall financial plan for their
clients that properly addresses their clients risk tolerance, proper asset
allocation and the achievement of their financial goals. |
|
Range of fees |
Morningstar and
PersonalFund.Com indicate that these can be as much as 4.5% of the amount
invested. |
If done with accounts that
do NOT include mutual funds, these fees tend not to exceed 3%. |
These accounts do NOT
include mutual funds and average 2.01% for accounts less than $500,000. |
|
Diversification |
Usually only within the
asset class of the particular fund. |
Each manager diversifies
well within the asset class that they represent; overlap may exist. |
Each manager diversifies
well within the asset class that they represent; overlap is managed to a
minimum. |
|
Methodology for investment discipline |
Although most have a
buy/sell discipline, there is a lot of “style drift” in order to achieve
return which is counterproductive to asset allocation. There is also a need
to sell prematurely if there are too many liquidations. |
Securities are only sold if
the manager no longer wishes to hold the security for whatever reason it
deems appropriate. There are no unnecessary liquidations. |
|
|
Usual selection process by investor |
Normally based on historical
returns and in many cases based on managers that are no longer with the fund. |
Manager selection is based
on the specific returns and qualitative factors of the manager. |
|
|
Tax efficiency (for non-retirement accounts only) |
You inherit any unrealized
capital gains when you enter the fund. |
You own the actual
securities so there are no unrealized capital gains when you enter a
portfolio. |
|
|
Tax harvesting (intentionally taking capital losses
to offset internal or external gains) |
Not available. |
Depending on the broker, and
your relationship with your tax advisor this may or may not be done. |
Your Curian advisor IS a CPA
and understands all tax ramifications. Curian automatically initiates this
process for ALL clients automatically. |
|
Minimum size of accounts |
As low as $100 |
Usually $100,000 per
manager. Proper diversification doesn't normally occur until the account is
greater than $250,000 |
$25,000 for the entire
account which will include complete diversification across all asset classes |
|
Transparency of holdings, reporting to shareholders,
disclosure |
A monthly statement is sent
out. Usually only the top 10% holdings 6 months after the fact are disclosed. |
You own the actual
securities and can see what you own as often as the manager reports, which is
usually everyday. |
|
|
Portfolio customization |
Not available. |
Some. Limited to the stocks
selected by each manager. |
Complete. Each manager has
their own selections but you can exclude by socially responsible issues or a
particular stock (i.e. if you already own a lot of a particular stock) |
|
Portfolio management |
Professional management with
no outside oversight. |
Institutional management
usually with some outside oversight, but not required. |
Institutional management
with complete outside oversight by a 3rd party named CRA Rogers
Casey. |
|
Fee structure |
Flat percentage, there is no
reduction based on size of account. |
The percentage charged is
reduced when reaching defined account levels. |
|